Make My Fish
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Make My Fish Menu

Menu Make My Fish-1
Menu Make My Fish-1
Menu Make My Fish-2
Menu Make My Fish-2
Menu Make My Fish-3
Menu Make My Fish-3
Menu Make My Fish-4
Menu Make My Fish-4
Menu Make My Fish-5
Menu Make My Fish-5
Menu Make My Fish-6
Menu Make My Fish-6
Menu Make My Fish-7
Menu Make My Fish-7
Menu Make My Fish-8
Menu Make My Fish-8

Bundles

Shrimp and Fish Combo Bundle
$22.75
Includes fries. Served with your choice of coca-cola product.
Shrimp and Chips
$17.25
Served with your choice of coca-cola product.
All Shrimp Bundle
$15.50
Served with your choice of coca-cola product.

Chicken Wings

Chicken and Chips
$15.25
All Chicken
$14.75
4 pieces.
Chicken Dinner
$20.50
Four pieces. Includes two sides.
Land and Sea Combo
$24.00
Three wings, seven jumbo shrimps, and fries.

Whiting Fish Fillet

Fish and Chips
$12.00
Four pieces.
Fish Sandwich
$11.00
four pieces.
All Fish
$13.75
Six pieces.
Fish and Grits
$14.50
Fish and Shrimp Combo
$23.00
Includes fries.
Fish Dinner
$19.75
Six pieces. Includes two sides.
Fish and Shrimp Dinner
$26.00

Catfish Fillet

Catfish Dinner
$20.50
Three pieces. Includes two sides.
Catfish Sandwich
$12.75
Three pieces.
Catfish and Chips
$14.75
Three pieces.
All Catfish
$15.75
Four pieces.
Catfish and Grits
$15.50
Three pieces.
Catfish and Shrimp Combo
$23.75
Includes fries.
Triple Play
$26.00
Two catfish, four whiting, seven jumbo shrimps, and fries.
Catfish and Shrimp Dinner
$27.50

Shrimp Jumbo

Shrimp and Fish Combo
$22.50
Includes fries.
All Shrimp
$15.50
Shrimp and Grits
$18.50
Prime Time Shrimp
$15.50
Shrimp Dinner
$23.00
Includes two sides.

Side Orders

Collard Greens
$6.50
Macaroni and Cheese
$6.50
Candied Yams
$6.50
French Fries
$4.50
Grits
$4.50
Potato salad
$6.00
Mac and cheese
$5.00

Beverages

Lemonade
$2.50
Ice Tea
$2.50
Fruit Punch
$2.50
Half and Half
$2.50
Canned Sodas
$1.25
Bottle water
$1.50

If you’re a seafood lover or just craving some classic Southern comfort food, Make My Fish offers a menu brimming with flavorful options that will leave you coming back for more. As a seasoned reviewer, I can say that their variety and quality truly stand out, with something for everyone.

For those who can’t decide between shrimp and fish, the Shrimp and Fish Combo Bundle is a perfect choice, offering a satisfying balance of both. If you’re a fan of shrimp, the Shrimp and Chips or the All Shrimp Bundle will definitely hit the spot, giving you a hearty portion of crispy shrimp paired with perfectly seasoned fries.

The Chicken Wings section is another crowd-pleaser, with options like Chicken and Chips for a simple yet filling meal, or the Chicken DinnerLand and Sea Combo for a more diverse feast that includes both seafood and juicy chicken wings.

For fish lovers, Make My Fish doesn’t disappoint. The Whiting Fish Fillet can be enjoyed in several ways: from the classic Fish and Chips to the Fish Sandwich for a handheld option. The Fish and Shrimp Combo is a particularly tempting choice for those who want to enjoy both types of seafood in one meal.

The Catfish Fillet options are equally as appealing. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty Catfish Dinner, a Catfish Sandwich, or the crispy goodness of Catfish and Chips, there’s a dish that’s bound to satisfy. For something extra comforting, try the Catfish and Grits.

Don’t forget the Shrimp Jumbo options – from the Prime Time Shrimp to the savory Shrimp and Grits, and the crowd-favorite Shrimp Dinner, these dishes are sure to delight shrimp enthusiasts.

Sides like Collard Greens, Macaroni and Cheese, and Candied Yams add the perfect finishing touch to your meal, while drinks like Lemonade, Ice Tea, and Fruit Punch keep things refreshing.

Make My Fish truly offers a diverse and delicious menu that promises a fulfilling meal for any craving.

Make My Fish

Make My Fish in New York City offers a delectable menu of Fish & Chips, Desserts, and Seafood. Enjoy their Shrimp and Fish Combo Bundle or try the Chicken Wings with a side. Customers rave about the catfish and shrimp dishes. Conveniently located on 120 W 116th St, Make My Fish is perfect for a quick bite or takeout. Experience the delicious flavors and friendly service today!

Follow Us
  • Yelp
  • instagram
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.